TN Online TestSamacheer Kalvi practice

Federalism in India - Study Notes

Share this chapter: Telegram

Lesson summary

Federalism is a political system in which the Constitution distributes and guarantees powers between a national government and regional governments. Where regions differ in ethnicity, language or religion, democratic federalism is the best instrument to ensure unity in diversity. The Constitution is the parent; the Centre and the States are its siblings.

Evolution

Federal features

  1. Written Constitution: powers of 28 State governments and one national government are clearly defined.
  2. Supremacy of the Constitution: no government can claim powers above it.
  3. Distribution of powers: the cardinal principle; India has three Lists, the USA a single mode.
  4. Bicameralism: Rajya Sabha (Council of States, guardian of States' rights) and Lok Sabha.
  5. Rigidity: Article 368 in Part XX lays down a special amendment procedure.
  6. Supreme Court: umpire of the federal system with original jurisdiction over Centre-State and inter-State disputes.

Unitary features

FeatureDetail
Single ConstitutionNo separate State Constitutions, unlike the USA
Single citizenshipNo State citizenship
FlexibilitySome provisions change by simple majority
No right to existenceArticles 3 and 4: Parliament reshapes States by ordinary law on the President's recommendation
Rajya SabhaSeats by population: Uttar Pradesh 31, Nagaland 1, Tamil Nadu 18; Article 249 transfers a State subject to Parliament
Imbalanced powersStrong Centre, weak States; residuary powers with the Union
Emergency powersArticles 352 to 360 in Part XVIII: 352 National, 356 State, 360 Financial
Integrated judiciarySupreme Court, High Courts and subordinate courts
Election CommissionOne machinery for Parliament and State legislatures
Unified auditingCAG under Article 148

Territory of India: 28 States, 8 Union Territories and acquired territories. The State Election Commission conducts local body elections under the 73rd and 74th Amendments and is not part of the federal system.

Centre-State relations

Legislative

Executive

Executive power follows the Lists. Concurrent subjects are ordinarily executed by States, but the Union can issue directions. Functions can be entrusted either way with consent; the Union can entrust a function to a State without its consent with Parliament's consent.

Financial

  1. Exclusive to the Centre: corporation tax, customs.
  2. Exclusive to States: sales tax.
  3. Levied by the Union, collected and kept by States: stamp duties, excise duties.
  4. Levied and collected by the Union, given to States: tax on newspaper advertisements.
  5. Levied and collected by the Union, shared: tax on non-agricultural income.

Non-tax revenue: Union from railways, posts and telegraphs, broadcasting; States from forests, irrigation, electricity, road transport. Finance Commission (Article 280): set up every five years by the President; a Chairman and four members; fourteen so far.

Cooperative federalism

Granville Austin called Indian federalism cooperative. India is quasi federal: the Centre can pull down a State through emergency powers.

River water disputes

Article 262 lets Parliament exclude courts. Negotiation comes first; failing that, an ad hoc tribunal whose head is nominated by the Chief Justice of India; its award is final. Cauvery: 1924 agreement, lapsed 1974, tribunal 1991, award 2007. Shares: Tamil Nadu 404.25 tmcft (177.25 at Biligundlu), Karnataka 284.25, Kerala 30, Puducherry 7.

Issues and commissions

Solved MCQs → Practice test →

More for this chapter

Book Back Questions11 textbook MCQs · solved Additional MCQs20 extra MCQs · solved Practice TestInteractive · instant score Book Back TestTest yourself on the textbook set Additional MCQ TestTest yourself on the extra set Formula SheetAll key formulas

More chapters in Political Science

View all
1 Constitution of India 2 Legislature 3 Executive 4 Indian Judiciary 6 Administrative Machinery in India 7 Challenges of Nation Building 8 Planning and Development Politics 9 India and the World 10 India and Its Neighbours 11 International Organisations 12 Environmental Concerns and Globalisation