Federalism in India - Study Notes
Lesson summary
Federalism is a political system in which the Constitution distributes and guarantees powers between a national government and regional governments. Where regions differ in ethnicity, language or religion, democratic federalism is the best instrument to ensure unity in diversity. The Constitution is the parent; the Centre and the States are its siblings.
Evolution
- The USA became the first federal State; Australia, Canada and trilingual Switzerland followed. The European Union is a voluntary federal formation.
- Regulating Act 1773: beginnings of federalism in modern India.
- Government of India Act 1919: partial autonomy (Dyarchy) in the Presidencies.
- Nehru Committee Report 1928: favoured a federal structure with more powers for States.
- Government of India Act 1935: provincial autonomy and a proposed Dyarchy at the Centre.
- The Seventh Schedule holds the three Lists.
Federal features
- Written Constitution: powers of 28 State governments and one national government are clearly defined.
- Supremacy of the Constitution: no government can claim powers above it.
- Distribution of powers: the cardinal principle; India has three Lists, the USA a single mode.
- Bicameralism: Rajya Sabha (Council of States, guardian of States' rights) and Lok Sabha.
- Rigidity: Article 368 in Part XX lays down a special amendment procedure.
- Supreme Court: umpire of the federal system with original jurisdiction over Centre-State and inter-State disputes.
Unitary features
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Single Constitution | No separate State Constitutions, unlike the USA |
| Single citizenship | No State citizenship |
| Flexibility | Some provisions change by simple majority |
| No right to existence | Articles 3 and 4: Parliament reshapes States by ordinary law on the President's recommendation |
| Rajya Sabha | Seats by population: Uttar Pradesh 31, Nagaland 1, Tamil Nadu 18; Article 249 transfers a State subject to Parliament |
| Imbalanced powers | Strong Centre, weak States; residuary powers with the Union |
| Emergency powers | Articles 352 to 360 in Part XVIII: 352 National, 356 State, 360 Financial |
| Integrated judiciary | Supreme Court, High Courts and subordinate courts |
| Election Commission | One machinery for Parliament and State legislatures |
| Unified auditing | CAG under Article 148 |
Territory of India: 28 States, 8 Union Territories and acquired territories. The State Election Commission conducts local body elections under the 73rd and 74th Amendments and is not part of the federal system.
Centre-State relations
Legislative
- Territorial: the Union law covers all of India and Indian citizens abroad (extra-territorial); State laws stop at State borders.
- List I Union: 100 subjects (defence, foreign affairs, banking, currency). List II State: 59 items (public order, police, public health, agriculture, forests). List III Concurrent: 52 items (criminal law, marriage, education); Parliament's law prevails in a clash.
- Residuary powers go to the Union. The scheme broadly follows the 1935 Act.
- Exceptions: National Emergency, agreement of two or more States, international agreements, Article 356 emergency.
Executive
Executive power follows the Lists. Concurrent subjects are ordinarily executed by States, but the Union can issue directions. Functions can be entrusted either way with consent; the Union can entrust a function to a State without its consent with Parliament's consent.
Financial
- Exclusive to the Centre: corporation tax, customs.
- Exclusive to States: sales tax.
- Levied by the Union, collected and kept by States: stamp duties, excise duties.
- Levied and collected by the Union, given to States: tax on newspaper advertisements.
- Levied and collected by the Union, shared: tax on non-agricultural income.
Non-tax revenue: Union from railways, posts and telegraphs, broadcasting; States from forests, irrigation, electricity, road transport. Finance Commission (Article 280): set up every five years by the President; a Chairman and four members; fourteen so far.
Cooperative federalism
Granville Austin called Indian federalism cooperative. India is quasi federal: the Centre can pull down a State through emergency powers.
- Inter-State Council (Article 263): enquires into disputes, discusses common subjects, recommends coordination. Set up in the early nineties on the Sarkaria Commission's advice; Prime Minister chairs it; a Standing Committee under the Union Home Minister.
- Zonal Councils: States Reorganization Act 1956; five at first, North Eastern added in 1971; Union Home Minister is common chairperson; Nehru: "develop the habit of co-operative working".
- River Boards: River Boards Act 1956.
- Water Disputes Tribunal: Inter-State Water Disputes Act 1956 under Article 262.
- NITI Aayog: January 2015, replacing the 65-year-old Planning Commission; Prime Minister chairs it.
River water disputes
Article 262 lets Parliament exclude courts. Negotiation comes first; failing that, an ad hoc tribunal whose head is nominated by the Chief Justice of India; its award is final. Cauvery: 1924 agreement, lapsed 1974, tribunal 1991, award 2007. Shares: Tamil Nadu 404.25 tmcft (177.25 at Biligundlu), Karnataka 284.25, Kerala 30, Puducherry 7.
Issues and commissions
- Governor's role, reservation of State bills, Article 356, education moved to the Concurrent List by the 42nd Amendment (1976), All India Services (Article 312).
- Administrative Reforms Commissions: first 1966 (Morarji Desai, then K. Hanumanthaiah, 20 reports); second 2005 (Veerappa Moily, then V. Ramachandran).
- Rajamannar Committee (Tamil Nadu; report 1971): Inter-State Council, drop Articles 256, 257, 339(2), residuary powers to States, abolish All India Services.
- Sarkaria Commission (1983; 247 recommendations): Article 263(b) and (c) only, Article 356 as last resort, eminent non-partisan Governors, three-language formula.
- Punchhi Commission (2007; report 2010): fixed tenure and impeachment for Governors, localised emergency.
- S.R. Bommai case (1994): limits on Article 356 and judicial review.
- Venkatachaliah Commission (NCRWC, 2000).