Indian Judiciary - Study Notes
Lesson summary
The judiciary is one of the three organs of government, along with the legislature and the executive. It interprets law, protects the Constitution and the rights of individuals, and in a federal polity like India acts as the protector of the federation by settling disputes between the Centre and the States.
Justice in ancient and medieval India
- In ancient monarchies the king was the highest judicial authority; his word was the final verdict.
- Disputes were mostly settled locally by caste bodies; the accused often had to prove innocence through ordeals by fire, water, poison, balance, lot and rice grains.
- Smritis such as Manusmriti upheld the varna order; there was no equality before law. Trade disputes went to guilds (srenis).
- In medieval India the Sultan was the supreme judicial authority, assisted by Muftis. In his absence Qazi-ul-Quzat presided over the courts. The post of Sadre Jahan was later created; Alauddin Khilji amalgamated the Sadre Jahan's Court with the Chief Justice's Court.
- Officers of the Chief Justice's Court: Mufti, Pandit, Mohtasib (prosecutions) and Dadbak (administrative officer).
Courts under the East India Company
| Year | Development |
|---|---|
| 1600 | Company incorporated by the Charter of Queen Elizabeth I |
| 1661 | Charter led to a Governor and Council in Madras |
| 1665 | Case of Mrs. Ascentia Dawas in Madras under Governor Fox Croft |
| 1668 | Charter gave the Company judicial authority over Bombay |
| 1678 | Streynsham Master reorganised the Madras judicial system |
| 1683 | Courts of Admiralty for crimes on the high seas |
| 1687 | Corporation of Madras with a Mayor's Court (Madras only) |
| 1726 | Mayor's Court in each of the three Presidencies |
| 1753 | Charter reformed the 1726 provisions and set up five courts |
| 1772 | Warren Hastings' Plan |
| 1773 | Regulating Act: Supreme Court of Judicature at Calcutta |
| 1793 | Cornwallis Code |
| 1801 / 1824 | Supreme Courts at Madras / Bombay |
| 1861 | Indian High Courts Act: High Courts at Calcutta, Madras, Bombay |
Federal Court to Supreme Court
- The Government of India Act, 1935 provided for a Federal Court; it was inaugurated in 1937 with a Chief Justice and six judges and worked for 12 years.
- Sir Hari Singh Gour in 1921 first saw the need for an All-India Court of Final Appeal in place of the Privy Council.
- The Abolition of the Privy Council Jurisdiction Act, 1949 made the Federal Court the highest court.
- Article 124 provided for the Supreme Court; it began functioning on 28 January 1950 in the Chamber of Princes and moved to its present building in 1958. Harilal J. Kania was the first Chief Justice.
Supreme Court
- Three-tier system: Supreme Court, High Courts, District and Sessions Courts. India has an integrated judiciary, not a dual one as in the USA.
- Jurisdiction: original (Centre-State and inter-State disputes), appellate (highest court of appeal) and advisory (the President may seek advice, which is not binding).
- Articles 124 to 147 deal with its composition. The Chief Justice consults a collegium of four senior-most judges. Judges retire at 65 and can be removed only through impeachment.
- Qualifications: citizen of India, and five years as a High Court judge, or ten years as a High Court advocate, or a distinguished jurist in the President's opinion.
High Courts and writs
- High Court judges retire at 62. Delhi alone among Union Territories has its own High Court.
- Under Article 226 the High Courts can issue writs. Habeas Corpus protects against illegal detention; Mandamus directs an authority to do its legal duty; Prohibition stops a lower court from exceeding its jurisdiction.
Judicial review, PIL and judicial activism
- Judicial review tests the constitutionality of laws and executive action, and even of amendments through the basic structure doctrine.
- PIL: Supreme Court under Article 32, High Court under Article 226, magistrate court under Section 133 CrPC; not against a private party. Examples: Common Cause (2005), Parmanand Katara.
- Judicial activism: term introduced by Arthur Schlesinger Jr. in 1947. A.K. Gopalan vs. State of Madras was followed by Menaka Gandhi vs. Union of India, which read fairness into Article 21.
Law, IPC and Lok Adalat
- Constitutional law is the supreme law; administrative law is subordinate to it and deals only with administration.
- Rule of Law: all are equal before law, nobody is above law, the same law applies to all.
- Indian Penal Code: drafted in 1860 on the recommendation of the first Law Commission (1834); in force from 1862.
- Lok Adalat: people's court for speedy settlement by mutual agreement; statutory status under the 1987 Act.
More for this chapter
Book Back Questions11 textbook MCQs · solved
Additional MCQs24 extra MCQs · solved
Practice TestInteractive · instant score
Book Back TestTest yourself on the textbook set
Additional MCQ TestTest yourself on the extra set
Formula SheetAll key formulas
More chapters in Political Science
View all
1 Constitution of India
2 Legislature
3 Executive
5 Federalism in India
6 Administrative Machinery in India
7 Challenges of Nation Building
8 Planning and Development Politics
9 India and the World
10 India and Its Neighbours
11 International Organisations
12 Environmental Concerns and Globalisation