Legislature - Study Notes
Lesson summary
The legislature is the highest law-making body. At the Centre it is called Parliament or the National Legislature; in the states and union territories it is the Legislative Assembly. Parliament shares law making with twenty-eight states and eight union territories.
The Parliament
- Two houses: the House of the People (Lok Sabha, lower house) and the Council of States (Rajya Sabha, upper house). This bicameral system was inspired by the British parliamentary system and the bicameral system of the USA.
- Three sessions a year: Budget Session (February-May), Monsoon Session (July-August) and Winter Session (November-December). The President summons Parliament, at least twice a year, and addresses the first session each year.
- Functions: legislative, financial (the budget), electoral (electing the President and Vice-President) and judicial (impeachment of the President, Vice-President and judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts).
- Quorum: one-tenth of the total members of the House.
Lok Sabha
- 545 members: 543 elected directly by voters aged 18 and above from 543 parliamentary constituencies, and 2 nominated Anglo-Indians. Majority is 272.
- Each parliamentary constituency comprises six assembly constituencies. Term: five years, while the ruling party keeps the confidence of the House.
- The leader of the ruling party is the Prime Minister, who selects the council of ministers.
The Speaker
- Elected by the Lok Sabha from among its members; conducts debates, keeps order and is administrative head of the parliamentary secretariat.
- Permits amendments to bills, refers questions of privilege to the Committee of Privileges, decides points of order and whether a bill is a money bill.
- Presides over joint sittings, recognises the Leader of Opposition and, under the 52nd Amendment, disqualifies members for defection.
- Votes only to break a tie (casting vote). Nehru called the Speaker a symbol of the nation's freedom and liberty.
Rajya Sabha
- Not more than 250 members: 238 elected by state MLAs by proportional representation through the single transferable vote, and 12 nominated by the President from literature, science, art and social service.
- Constituted on 3rd April 1952; protects the rights of the states like the US Senate, but seats follow population: Uttar Pradesh 31, Tamil Nadu 18, Sikkim 1 (fourth schedule).
- Permanent house: never dissolved; one-third retire every second year; term six years.
- The Vice-President is ex-officio Chairman. A member must be a citizen and at least 30 years old.
Privileges of members
- Freedom of speech and immunity from court proceedings for anything said or any vote in Parliament.
- Freedom from arrest in civil cases during the session and forty days before and after it.
Powers of the two Houses
| Area | Position of the Rajya Sabha |
|---|---|
| Equal | Ordinary bills, constitutional amendment bills, election and impeachment of the President, approval of ordinances and emergencies |
| Unequal | Money bill only in Lok Sabha; returned within 14 days; cannot vote on demands for grants; cannot pass no-confidence motion |
| Special | Article 249 (law on a State List subject) and Article 312 (new All-India Service); alone starts removal of the Vice-President |
Law making process
- First Reading: introduction; no discussion. A private member gives one month's notice.
- Publication in the Gazette of India.
- Second Reading after two days: consider at once, send to a select committee or joint select committee, or circulate for public opinion.
- Committee Stage, Report Stage (clause-by-clause debate) and Third Reading (formal approval).
- The other House repeats the stages; then the President's assent.
If the other House rejects the bill or holds it for six months, the President may call a joint session presided by the Speaker. Private member bills are taken on alternate Fridays from 2 pm to 6 pm; only fourteen have passed, the last in 1970. Trichy Siva's Rights of Transgender Persons Bill, 2014 is a private member bill.
Ordinary bill and money bill
| Ordinary bill | Money bill |
|---|---|
| Either House; minister or private member | Lok Sabha only; minister only, on the President's recommendation |
| Rajya Sabha can amend or reject; can hold six months | Rajya Sabha cannot amend or reject; holds 14 days |
| Joint sitting possible | No joint sitting; Speaker's certificate needed |
| President may return it | President cannot return it |
Distribution of powers
The Seventh Schedule has three lists. Union List: defence, atomic energy, foreign affairs, banking, railways, currency. State List: agriculture, police, prisons, local government, public health, land. Concurrent List: education, forests, trade unions, adulteration, adoption and succession. Union law prevails in a conflict; residuary power lies with the Centre.
Amendment (Article 368)
- Simple majority: new states, legislative councils, quorum, salaries of MPs, number of Supreme Court judges, citizenship.
- Special majority (more than half of total membership and two-thirds present and voting, at the third reading): fundamental rights, directive principles.
- Special majority plus ratification by half of the states: election of the President, the Supreme Court and High Courts, Seventh Schedule lists, Article 368 itself.
- No joint sitting; the President must give assent.
State legislature
- Part VI, Articles 152 to 237. A state with only a Legislative Assembly is unicameral; with a Legislative Council it is bicameral.
- Governor: constitutional head, appointed by the President for five years; citizen, at least 35 years old.
- Chief Minister: appointed by the Governor (Article 164(1)); heads the cabinet and council of ministers; real executive head. Article 163(1) provides the council of ministers.
- Speaker and Deputy Speaker are elected by the members; the Speaker has a casting vote and appoints committee chairmen.
- Committees: standing (financial, departmental, inquiry, scrutiny, day-to-day business, house-keeping) and ad hoc (inquiry and advisory).