TN Online TestSamacheer Kalvi practice

The Dying Detective, The House on Elm Street and A Dilemma

10th Standard · English · #7

Unit 7 of 10th English is about mysteries. It contains the prose play The Dying Detective by Arthur Conan Doyle, the poem The House on Elm Street by Nadia Bush and the supplementary story A Dilemma by Silas Weir Mitchell, with homophones, commonly confused words and simple, complex and compound sentences.

Study this chapter

Asked in previous board exams

2 questions from this chapter came in 1 past public exams. Open any of them to see the answer and explanation.

  1. March 2026
    Choose the appropriate synonym for the italicised word. There was a sudden rush and scuffle.
    See answer in the solved paper →
  2. March 2026
    Choose the appropriate antonym for the italicised word. I saw a frail man with bald head sitting.
    See answer in the solved paper →

About The Dying Detective, The House on Elm Street and A Dilemma

Easy ~60 min study

The seventh unit of the Class 10 English textbook is built around mystery and investigation. The prose lesson shows Sherlock Holmes pretending to be dying in order to trap a murderer, the poem describes a lonely, silent house that no one understands, and the supplementary story leaves a poor clerk with a box of jewels that may explode if he opens it.

Alongside the lessons the unit practises homophones and commonly confused words, a listening task about stolen cakes, and the transformation of sentences between simple, complex and compound forms. Writing tasks cover reviews, pamphlets and letters of enquiry.

This page gathers one mark questions from the book exercises of the unit together with additional questions drawn from the lessons, the glossary and the grammar section, each with its answer and a short explanation.

What you'll learn

  • Narrate how Sherlock Holmes trapped Culverton Smith into confessing the murder of Victor Savage.
  • Identify the characters of The Dying Detective and their roles.
  • Explain why the house and the tree in The House on Elm Street are mysterious, and find the rhyme scheme.
  • Describe Tom's dilemma over the iron box in A Dilemma.
  • Choose the correct homophone to complete a sentence.
  • Transform sentences between simple, complex and compound forms.

Before you start

  • Phrases, clauses, finite and non-finite verbs learnt in the previous unit.
  • Knowledge of coordinating and subordinating conjunctions.
  • A first reading of the three lessons in the unit.

Topics covered in this chapter

The Dying Detective Arthur Conan Doyle's story of Sherlock Holmes faking a deadly illness to make Culverton Smith confess to murder.
Characters of the story Sherlock Holmes, Dr. Watson, Mrs. Hudson, Culverton Smith, Inspector Morton and the dead Victor Savage.
The House on Elm Street Nadia Bush's 'dark' poem about a mysterious house and a tree that never grows leaves.
Rhyme scheme and figures of speech Rhyming words of each stanza, and synecdoche, paradox, onomatopoeia and rhetorical questions.
A Dilemma Silas Weir Mitchell's story of Tom and an iron box of jewels that may explode when unlocked.
Homophones and confused words Words that sound alike such as new and knew, and pairs such as brought and bought, affect and effect.
Listening: the stolen cakes A detective investigates a theft at Ms. Gervis' apartment in which only her cakes were taken.
Simple, complex and compound sentences Identifying the three kinds of sentences and transforming one into another.

The Dying Detective, The House on Elm Street and A Dilemma explained

What this unit covers

The Dying Detective (Prose)

Mrs. Hudson tells Dr. Watson that Sherlock Holmes has not eaten for three days and is dying. Holmes refuses to let Watson examine him, claims a contagious disease from Sumatra and sends Watson to fetch Culverton Smith, a planter who knows the disease. Hidden in the next room, Watson hears Smith confess to killing his nephew Victor Savage with a poisoned box, and Inspector Morton arrests him. Holmes's illness was three days of fasting and make-up.

The House on Elm Street (Poem)

Nadia Bush describes a lonely house that is large yet bare to the bone, whose lights flicker at night and whose tree never grows leaves or changes in size. The speaker drives past it almost every day but fear stops her from going in. Rumours grow, the house fades, and what happened inside will always be a mystery.

A Dilemma (Supplementary)

Uncle Philip, a malicious inventor, leaves his nephew Tom an iron box of rubies, diamonds and pearls with a letter warning that it will explode dynamite when unlocked. Tom spends two years unable to open it, loses his fiancee Susan, changes his name and finally wills the box to a society.

Grammar

A simple sentence has one finite verb, a complex sentence has one main clause and one or more subordinate clauses, and a compound sentence has two main clauses joined by a coordinating conjunction. The unit practises changing one kind into another, together with homophones such as new and knew and confused words such as affect and effect.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Choosing 'probably' to rewrite 'definitely'. Definitely means certainly; probably only shows possibility.
  • Saying Ms. Gervis lost money or jewellery. The robber stole nothing but her cakes.
  • Naming Susan or Uncle Philip as the person Tom consulted for a way to open the box. The book's answer is Professor Clinch.
  • Mixing up homophones such as herd and heard, peace and piece. Check the meaning, not only the sound.
  • Calling a sentence with 'and', 'but' or 'yet' complex. Two main clauses joined by a coordinating conjunction make a compound sentence.

Test yourself on these with the practice test, then check the worked reasoning in the solved MCQs.

Frequently asked questions

Why did Holmes pretend to be dying?

Holmes knew that Culverton Smith had killed his nephew Victor Savage with a rare disease but could not prove it. By pretending to have caught the same disease through a box sent by post, he made Smith come to gloat and confess, while Watson listened from the next room and Inspector Morton waited outside.

Why was Holmes rude to Watson?

Holmes insulted Watson's ability as a doctor so that Watson would fetch Culverton Smith instead of treating him. He also did not want Watson to know he was not really ill, because Watson's genuine worry made the deception convincing. Afterwards he apologised and thanked him.

How did Holmes make himself look ill?

He fasted for three days, taking neither food nor drink, and used make-up to give himself a gaunt, flushed look. The talk of half-crowns and coins was meant to prove that he was delirious. When Smith was arrested, Holmes asked for something nutritious to eat.

Why is the house on Elm Street a mystery?

No one knows what happened in the house. It sits alone, large but bare, its lights flicker on and off at night, and the tree beside it never grows leaves or changes in size. Rumours are constantly made about it, and the poet guesses it will always be a mystery.

What was the dilemma in A Dilemma?

Tom inherited an iron box said to contain rubies, diamonds and pearls, along with a letter warning that it would explode supersensitive dynamite when unlocked. If he believed the letter he could never enjoy the wealth; if he doubted it and opened the box he might be blown to atoms.

Who is Silas Weir Mitchell?

Silas Weir Mitchell (1829-1914) was an American neurologist from Philadelphia, considered the father of neurology and a pioneer in scientific medicine. He published more than 25 literary titles, and his medical background gave his fiction psychological insight. An American Academy of Neurology award is named after him.

What is the difference between complex and compound sentences?

A complex sentence has one main clause and one or more subordinate clauses, as in 'Ramu is so poor that he cannot buy a bicycle'. A compound sentence has two main clauses joined by a coordinating conjunction such as and, but, yet or otherwise, as in 'Ramu is very poor and he cannot buy a bicycle'.

Last updated 29 September 2026

More chapters in English

View all
1 His First Flight, Life and The Tempest 2 The Night the Ghost Got In, The Grumble Family and Zigzag 3 Empowered Women Navigating the World, I am Every Woman and The Story of Mulan 4 The Attic, The Ant and the Cricket and The Aged Mother 5 Tech Bloomers, The Secret of the Machines and A Day in 2889 6 The Last Lesson, No Men Are Foreign and The Little Hero of Holland