Index Numbers - Study Notes
Chapter summary
An index number is a relative measure that compares and describes the average change in price, quantity or value of an item or a group of related items with respect to time, geographic location or other characteristics. It is a specialized average and is viewed as a barometer of economic activity: it reveals inflationary or deflationary tendencies. The chapter opens with Irving Fisher (1867-1947), who made important contributions to index numbers.
Definitions quoted in the book
- Maslow: a numerical value characterizing the change in complex economic phenomenon over a period of time or space.
- Spiegel: a statistical measure designed to show changes in a variable or a group of related variables with respect to time, geographical location or other characteristics.
- Croxton and Cowden: devices for measuring differences in the magnitude of a group of related variables.
- Bowley: a series which reflects in its trend and fluctuations the movements of some quantity.
Uses
- Show the pulse of the economy and inflationary or deflationary tendencies.
- Measure trends in prices, population and production over time.
- Expressed in percentages, so they are easy to compare.
- Help frame economic and business policies; consumer price indices fix dearness allowance.
- Deflate data for price changes and measure the purchasing power of money.
- Compare standards of living across periods and places.
- A special type of average: they average variables with different units.
Types
| Type | Measures |
|---|---|
| Price index | Net relative change in prices; wholesale and retail price indices |
| Quantity index | Changes in volume produced, purchased or consumed |
| Value index | Total value of a period against the base period (stock, sales, profit) |
Precautions in construction: purpose, base period, commodities, price quotations, weights, average and formula. The base period is the period against which comparison is made and must be free from natural calamities.
Unweighted index numbers
- Simple aggregative method: \( P_{01} = \frac{\sum p_1}{\sum p_0} \times 100 \). Limitations: relative importance of commodities is ignored, and highly priced items influence the index.
- Simple average of price relatives: AM \( P_{01} = \frac{1}{N} \sum \frac{p_1}{p_0} \times 100 \); GM \( P_{01} = \text{antilog}\left( \frac{\sum \log P}{N} \right) \). Advantages: not influenced by extreme prices; price relatives are pure numbers, so units do not matter. Limitations: equal weights for all items; GM is difficult to calculate.
Weighted aggregative index numbers
| Index | Formula | Weights |
|---|---|---|
| Laspeyre | \( \frac{\sum p_1q_0}{\sum p_0q_0} \times 100 \) | Base-year quantities |
| Paasche | \( \frac{\sum p_1q_1}{\sum p_0q_1} \times 100 \) | Current-year quantities, continuously revised |
| Dorbish and Bowley | \( \frac{P^{L} + P^{P}}{2} \) | Arithmetic mean of L and P |
| Fisher's ideal | \( \sqrt{P^{L} \times P^{P}} \) | Geometric mean of L and P |
| Marshall-Edgeworth | \( \frac{\sum p_1q_0 + \sum p_1q_1}{\sum p_0q_0 + \sum p_0q_1} \times 100 \) | \( q_0 + q_1 \) |
| Kelly | \( \frac{\sum p_1q}{\sum p_0q} \times 100 \) | Fixed q, for example \( \frac{q_0 + q_1}{2} \) |
Worked example from the book (Example 6.6): \( \sum p_1q_0 = 200 \), \( \sum p_0q_0 = 160 \), \( \sum p_1q_1 = 130 \), \( \sum p_0q_1 = 103 \) give Laspeyre 125, Paasche 126.21, Dorbish and Bowley 125.6, Fisher 125.61 and Marshall-Edgeworth 125.48.
Weighted average of price relatives
- Price relative \( P = \frac{p_1}{p_0} \times 100 \), weight \( w = p_0q_0 \).
- AM: \( P_{01} = \frac{\sum wP}{\sum w} \). GM: \( P_{01} = \text{antilog}\left( \frac{\sum w \log P}{\sum w} \right) \).
Quantity index numbers
- Laspeyre: \( Q_{01}^{L} = \frac{\sum q_1p_0}{\sum q_0p_0} \times 100 \).
- Paasche: \( Q_{01}^{P} = \frac{\sum q_1p_1}{\sum q_0p_1} \times 100 \).
- Fisher: \( Q_{01}^{F} = \sqrt{Q^{L} \times Q^{P}} \).
Tests for index numbers
- Time reversal test: the index reckoned forward is the reciprocal of the index reckoned backward, \( P_{01} \times P_{10} = 1 \).
- Factor reversal test: price index times quantity index equals the value index, \( P_{01} \times Q_{01} = \frac{\sum p_1q_1}{\sum p_0q_0} \).
- Circular test: an extension of time reversal to any years, \( P_{01} \times P_{12} \times P_{20} = 1 \). Many index numbers do not satisfy it.
- Fisher's ideal index satisfies the time reversal and factor reversal tests.
Consumer price index numbers
Also called cost of living index numbers, they show the effect of price changes on people as consumers. Uses: wage negotiations and dearness allowance, wage, price and rent policy, taxation, and measuring purchasing power and real income.
- Aggregate expenditure method (based on Laspeyre): \( \frac{\sum p_1q_0}{\sum p_0q_0} \times 100 \).
- Family budget method (weighted relatives): \( \frac{\sum wP}{\sum w} \) with \( w = p_0q_0 \).